"If everything works wonderfully, we hope to break ground next spring on 10 homes," Larry Mawby told the Leelanau Enterprise in May, describing Peninsula Housing's planned neighborhood at 980 Herman Road in Suttons Bay Township. Ten homes sounds like a small number. In Leelanau County it explains a lot about this year's sale prices, and it ties back to the numbers this post covers.
Leelanau's monthly price headlines swung hard this fall, up in September and down in October. If you're comparing Leelanau with Grand Traverse or Benzie, neither month tells you what a home costs here. The year-to-date figures do, and they show a middle that has hardly moved since 2025 while the top of the market pulls the average higher.
September said prices soared, October said they fell
According to Aspire North REALTORS®, Leelanau County's median single-family sale price for September 2026 was $750,000, compared with $605,000 in September 2025. That's a gain of about 24%. A month later, the October 2026 median came in at $565,000, compared with $792,000 in October 2025, a drop of about 29%.
Home values did not climb by a quarter and then fall by more than a quarter over eight weeks. The county had 43 sales in September 2026 and 37 in October. With so few sales, a handful of higher- or lower-priced closings can move a single month's median a long way, and the same thing can happen in the other direction a year later.
The past four Octobers make the point. Leelanau's October median went from $520,000 in 2023 to $600,000 in 2024, $792,000 in 2025 and $565,000 in 2026. Those swings come from a small county closing a different mix of homes each fall.
The year-to-date median is where it was in 2025
Once you add up more months, the noise mostly cancels out. Here are Aspire North's year-to-date Leelanau figures:
| Period | Sales | Median price | Average price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan–Sept 2025 | 281 | $650,000 | $842,191 |
| Jan–Sept 2026 | 287 | $650,000 | $933,204 |
| Jan–Oct 2025 | 329 | $670,000 | $862,220 |
| Jan–Oct 2026 | 324 | $649,000 | $923,537 |
Through September, the median was exactly the same both years. Through October, it was $21,000 lower in 2026. Sales were nearly identical too. For the home in the middle of the Leelanau market, 2026 has been a flat year.
The average tells a different story. It rose from $862,220 for January through October 2025 to $923,537 for the same months of 2026, about 7%. When the average rises and the median doesn't, the gain is coming from the top. More money went into expensive homes, and the homes in the middle sold for about what they did last year. The gap between the two figures grew from about $192,000 to about $274,500 over that span.
The regional numbers point the same way. Across Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim and Kalkaska counties, 34 homes sold for $1 million or more in October 2026, compared with 30 in October 2025, according to Aspire North's October market update.
A flat middle and a shrinking number of sales
A flat median could mean demand in the middle has cooled. The longer record says the bigger issue is how few homes change hands. Leelanau recorded 454 sales from January through October 2021, at a median of $420,000. For the same months of 2026, it recorded 324 sales at a median of $649,000. That's about 29% fewer sales and a median roughly 54% higher. Total dollar volume still rose, from about $261.6 million to about $299.2 million, because each sale is worth so much more.
A county that sells 130 fewer homes a year than it did five years ago isn't short of buyers. It's short of homes coming up for sale, and the shortage is worst in the price range most people shop.
That leaves a middle-market buyer facing a thin market more than a rising one. The price of a typical Leelanau home has held near $650,000 since 2025. What has changed is how many of those homes are for sale at any one time, and that changes how a search goes more than the median does.
Why the middle has trouble adding homes
New supply is what usually loosens a tight middle market, and the modest homes planned in Leelanau are few and still years from move-in. Three efforts show the scale.
In Suttons Bay Township, Peninsula Housing, a community land trust, plans a 38-home neighborhood on 8.2 acres at 980 Herman Road. The first site plan calls for 12 duplexes and six single-family homes. The township board approved the project's zoning request on May 13, 2026, and the Suttons Bay Township planning page lists the planning commission's review as on hold. The developer's stated goal is to break ground on the first 10 homes in spring 2027 and add about 10 more each year after that.
In Leelanau Township, the township approved a memorandum of understanding at its October meeting with HomeStretch for attainable housing on about 3.5 acres at 824 N. Warren Street in Northport, the Leelanau Enterprise reported. The proposal is for 26 two-bedroom rentals of about 900 square feet, with construction estimated from May 2027 to July 2028, according to the Enterprise's August report. Those are rentals, not homes for sale, but they may still help the middle by giving some local workers an option other than buying.
The Sleeping Bear Gateways Council takes a third approach. It raises private money to buy land for workforce housing and puts the land into a community land trust for 99 years, so land cost stays out of the home's price.
Interest in this kind of housing is wide. The Leelanau County Housing Collaborative's survey drew 1,689 responses from all 11 townships, and 81% named affordable housing for local workers a major issue, the Leelanau Ticker reported on Nov. 11. Respondents favored smaller-lot single-family homes at 76% and duplexes at 70%.
Even if every project above stays on schedule, the earliest groundbreaking target is spring 2027, and the Herman Road neighborhood is planned in phases of about 10 homes. For anyone buying in Leelanau over the next year, the homes for sale are mostly the ones that already exist.
What this means if you're comparing Leelanau with nearby counties
Across all five counties, the year-to-date median through October 2026 was $430,000, compared with $405,000 for the same months of 2025. In Grand Traverse County, the October 2026 median was $481,250, on 146 sales. Leelanau's year-to-date median of $649,000 is well above both.
If the region's middle keeps rising while Leelanau's holds, the gap between Leelanau and nearby counties shrinks. Leelanau doesn't get cheaper, but buying here costs less extra than it did in 2025. Whether the gap keeps shrinking depends on the next few quarters of year-to-date data, not on any single month.
Three habits will serve you better than the headlines. Compare year-to-date figures, not single months. Look at the average and the median together, because the space between them shows how much of the market is high-end. And treat the number of sales as a sign of how many homes you'll get to choose from, which matters more in Leelanau right now than the median does. Our guide to Leelanau waterfront versus inland homes covers how those two types of property differ, and the Leelanau neighborhood page and Suttons Bay page cover the towns.
A few questions buyers ask about these numbers
Did Leelanau prices drop in October 2026? The October median was lower than a year earlier, but October had only 37 sales. Through October, the county's median was $649,000, compared with $670,000 a year earlier, and the average rose about 7%.
Should I wait for the Herman Road or Warren Street projects? The developer's goal is to break ground on the first Herman Road homes in spring 2027, and the township lists its review as on hold. The Warren Street project is rentals, with construction estimated from May 2027 to July 2028. Neither will add many homes for sale in the next year.
Is Leelanau's median a good guide to what a specific home will sell for? No. Aspire North itself notes that average and median prices are market indicators and don't represent the value of any one property. In a county this size, the recent sales nearest the home in question tell you more.
If you're weighing Leelanau against Grand Traverse or Benzie and want to see what's selling in the price range you're shopping, talk it over with Joe Van Antwerp. Contact Joe for a free consultation, or start with a home valuation if you're thinking about selling in Leelanau first.